Episode #211 - “I’m Fine”: Nicolette Loeffler on the Cost of the Push-Through Mentality

Episode #211 - “I’m Fine”: Nicolette Loeffler on the Cost of the Push-Through Mentality
The Mental Matchup

For nearly a year and a half, Division I tennis player Nicolette Loeffler kept competing through severe pain, weight loss, and test results that kept coming back normal. She became an expert at saying “I’m fine,” afraid that slowing down meant falling behind. She was eventually diagnosed with Median Arcuate Ligament Syndrome (MALS) and had open abdominal surgery during her senior season at Fairfield University.

In this episode, Nicolette talks about athlete mental health, identity, chronic illness, and what happens when the “push through it” culture of sports follows you too far. She also shares why she created ARMOR OFF, a platform for the person behind the performance.

In this episode, we talk about:

  • Why “I’m fine” becomes so easy to say, and the fear of falling behind

  • The long road to a MALS diagnosis when every test came back normal

  • Facing surgery while still worrying about missing tennis

  • Why vulnerability and asking for help are a form of strength

  • The story behind ARMOR OFF and the conversations it aims to start

About our guest

Nicolette Loeffler is a senior at Fairfield University from Cold Spring Harbor, NY, majoring in Psychology with a minor in Education. A Division I women’s tennis player, she was part of a MAAC Championship team and earned First Team All-MAAC honors in singles and doubles. She is the founder of ARMOR OFF, an athlete-focused platform on mental health, identity, illness, injury, and pressure.

Connect with Nicolette on Instagram at ArmorOffProject and NicoletteLoeffler
Connect with Morgan’s Message on IG here
Connect with Morgan’s Message here

Next
Next

Episode #210 - Finding Yourself in the In-Between: Kiana Imani-Davis on Injury, Identity, and Moving Forward