Episode #208 - Rethinking Mental Toughness with Olivia Papakyrikos, M.Ed, LMHC, LPC

Episode #208 - Rethinking Mental Toughness with Olivia Papakyrikos, M.Ed, LMHC, LPC
The Mental Matchup

Athletes are often taught that toughness means pushing through, staying quiet, and never showing weakness. This week, Olivia Papakyrikos, M.Ed, LMHC, LPC, joins us to challenge that idea.

Olivia is a Boston-based therapist and mental performance consultant, and a former collegiate field hockey player at Wheaton College. She shares two personal stories that shaped her work: a coach who asked “How are you?” a second time, and a moment on a grocery store floor when her friends chose to sit down beside her instead of telling her to get up.

We talk about why relationships matter as much as resilience, what perfectionism and pressure do to athletes behind the scenes, and how asking for help is part of sustained success rather than a sign of failure.

In this episode, we talk about:

  • Why athletes get so good at saying “I’m fine”

  • Balancing school, sport, leadership, and social life while trying to be perfect

  • What real support looks like (hint: it’s not always fixing the problem)

  • Redefining mental toughness and resilience

  • Practical tools for navigating pressure and adversity

  • Supporting the person behind the athlete

    Connect with Olivia on her website here
    Connect with Olivia on IG here
    Email with Olivia here
    Connect with Morgan’s Message on IG here
    Connect with Morgan’s Message here

Next
Next

Episode #207 - Normalizing the Conversation: Mental Health and Caring for Our Most Vulnerable Youth with Mike O’Connor